The Emperor Norton Paradoxon
„Norton was in his day a respectable merchant, and since he has worn the Imperial purple he has shed no blood, robbed nobody, and despoiled the country of no one, which is more than can be said of any of his fellows in that line.“ (Daily Alta California from 22 January 1867)
Throughout history, there have been so many leaders of major nations who, through their actions, whether directly or indirectly, have caused the deaths of countless thousands or even millions of people. Yet, such politicians are still revered by many. H#tler, Stalin, Mao, Bokassa, you name it. There is even a kind of general consensus that politicians who were "only" responsible for the deaths of a few thousand people should be viewed with particular leniency, especially when their policies, while causing suffering, also improved the lives of many others.
The many people who lost everything, who had to suffer and die, are then simply nothing more than an inconvenient, necessary collateral damage. That is horrible. If someone who is not the leader of a state, murders one or more people, that person is called a murderer, a criminal, or a madman, someone who must be imprisoned or, in countries that have the death penalty, executed, in order to atone for the wrong they have committed and to protect society from them. However, if someone is a national leader and leads thousands, or even millions, of people into suffering and death, there will certainly be many who condemn him. Yet, there will always be many others who continue to view him as a brilliant visionary, a father of the nation, a great reformer, a modernizer, a revolutionary, a forward-thinking pioneer, and so on. And both those who hate and condemn him, and those who love and revere him, will agree on one thing: that he was a head of state. For better or worse, he was a true head of state.
But how is it that someone like Emperor Norton is viewed by many as a clown and not as a true head of state? Why is Emperor Norton not perceived by most people as a genuine, legitimate statesman, but rather as a (harmless) crackpot? What makes Emperor Norton I less legitimate than, for example, Emperor Napoleon I? If you walk through the streets today, you see an increasing number of individuals who are clearly mentally deranged and/or whose mental clarity is severely impaired by drug use.
A symptom of our destructive era, an age defined by crises and conflicts, which an increasing number of people can no longer endure, leading them to seek refuge in drugs and/or madness. Depending on the country, such individuals are either ignored or, if they commit criminal offenses, sometimes arrested and locked away for a period of time. In the grip of their delusions, some of these people express grandiose ideas, such as the belief that they literally own the city. Is their claim recognized? Do they receive any privileges? No. They are ignored, though some people may offer these pitiable figures a bit of money or food as a donation.
Emperor Norton was not that kind of person. At one time, he had been one of the wealthiest merchants in San Francisco. A failed speculative venture involving Peruvian rice cost him his entire fortune and forced him to close his business. Afterward, he lived in bitter poverty and isolation. This came as a shock to him, and he began to grapple with the injustices of the system. In itself, this is not unusual; many statesmen have found the impetus for their political endeavors in the experience of injustice or personal slights. Napoleon Bonaparte, for instance, was frequently teased as a schoolboy and did not get along well with most of his teachers. On one occasion, when a teacher attempted to humiliate him in front of the class, he reportedly exclaimed something to the effect of: "We bow only to God, and to no one else!"
Joshua Norton was a native-born citizen of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. Consequently, the concept of a monarchy was very familiar to him. Moreover, in San Francisco, he was living in a city that had once been part of an empire, an empire in the Napoleonic style, where the throne was occupied not by a prince from an ancient, high-ranking noble house, but by a soldier from an upper-middle-class family: the First Mexican Empire, which existed from 1821 to 1823 and that had included California and thus also the City of San Francisco, within its borders. The soldier who had become Emperor of Mexico was General Agustín de Iturbide. At the beginning of the Mexican War of Independence, he had fought against independence as a Spanish officer, but later sided with the revolutionaries, thereby contributing significantly to the success of Mexican independence. Initially, the Mexicans wanted a Spanish prince to serve as emperor. However, since Spain, until 1836, strictly refused to diplomatically recognize Mexico’s independence and, in fact, repeatedly attempted to reconquer the country, the plan to have a Spanish prince as emperor was quickly abandoned.
Instead, General Agustín de Iturbide was appointed to lead the young nation, initially as president (much like General George Washington, who became the first president of the United States), but subsequently as emperor. Emperor Agustín I was overthrown in 1823 because he ruled unconstitutionally, governing alone and authoritatively by decree, without a parliament. This ran counter to the spirit of the Mexican Revolution. In 1824, after an unsuccessful attempt to seize power once again, he was executed by firing squad. Between 1846 and 1848, the United States of America defeated the United Mexican States in a war and annexed large territories including Texas and California. As a republic, Mexico remained highly unstable, shaken by crises and civil wars. The negative memories of the brief reign of Emperor Agustín I faded, and quite a few Mexicans, including those now living in territories ceded by Mexico to the United States, looked back with wistful longing at the imperial grandeur and splendor of the empire.
Around the time Joshua Norton arrived in California, the then-relatively new Mormon religion had established a theocratic state, known as the State of Deseret, the precursor to the modern-day State of Utah, right next to California. Initially, the ideas of the Mormons met with widespread rejection along the East Coast of the United States; consequently, many Mormons, under the leadership of their second Prophet Brigham Young, headed further west to establish their own theocratic state, based on their own vision, within territory that had formerly belonged to Mexico.
From this perspective, it was not all that crazy for Joshua Norton, who, following his bankruptcy, had nothing left to lose in material terms, to come up with the idea of becoming an emperor. An emperor who would ensure a more just, fairer society. If soldiers can become emperors, why shouldn’t merchants be able to become emperors, too? Take, for instance, the Karađorđević dynasty, the Serbian, and later Yugoslav, royal house, which began as merchants before rising to royal status at the start of the 19th century as revolutionaries against imperial Ottoman rule.
As a member of a jury and as an (unsuccessful) candidate for the U.S. Congress, Joshua Norton had gained his first experience with the business of government. And so, he set to work with fresh energy on his new project: becoming Emperor. Not through subversion. Not through terrorism. Not through a violent uprising. No. His way was 100% peacefully. Joshua Norton started with a proclamation that was then printed by a local newspaper that found the whole thing amusing. And then, he simply became Emperor. Joshua Norton just started being Emperor. He carried out his role with such inner conviction, and for the general good and delight of all, that he increasingly enjoyed privileges typically reserved for a genuine head of state. He was provided with an officer’s uniform from the local U.S. Army base. He issued his own currency, which gained general acceptance. He released proclamations that were published in newspapers.
He mediated disputes. He was allowed to dine for free at many restaurants, which he would then designate as "purveyors to the imperial court", a distinction the establishments were proud to display. He was present at virtually every public event. He held a place of honor at the opera; everyone would rise for the Emperor, only taking their seats once he had taken his. He settled disagreements. He single-handedly prevented a pogrom in Chinatown. When the uniform that had been gifted to him by the U.S. Army became quite worn out, the San Francisco City Hall provided him with a splendid new one, in return for which Emperor Norton elevated the council members to the nobility. Police officers would salute him with military precision; he would review parades; he was widely liked and respected. He had great visions for the future of San Francisco, indeed, the construction of the Golden Gate Bridge might never have come to pass were it not for Emperor Norton. And so on and so forth. Emperor Norton was the pride of San Francisco, and he was untouchable.
Few statesmen have bestowed as much good and, above all, so little harm upon their subjects as did His Imperial Majesty Norton I, Emperor of the United States of America and Protector of Mexico, during his reign in San Francisco, which lasted from 1859 until his death in 1880. One must also keep in mind that this was the era of the Wild West. Washington, D.C., on the East Coast, was a very long way off. As an imperial capital, San Francisco brought a luster and significance to the West Coast that would have been unthinkable without Emperor Norton.
But why, then, is Emperor Norton generally not taken serious as a statesman?
How is it that mass-murdering figures like H#tler, Stalin, and their ilk are generally taken seriously, while someone like Emperor Norton is not? One might almost conclude that whether or not a ruler is taken seriously depends on their use of force. It seems that deranged, genocidal despots, regardless of how many lives they have on their conscience, are still regarded as legitimate statesmen, whether they hold the title of emperor, king, chancellor, president, general secretary, or otherwise; meanwhile, a fundamentally good-hearted man like Emperor Norton is, outside of San Francisco, generally dismissed as nothing more than a delusional, megalomaniacal crackpot in a uniform.
As long as the world takes mass murderers seriously as statesmen, yet ridicules someone like Emperor Norton, it will remain in the deplorable state in which it has been for so long. A humanity that views violence, in some sense, as a defining quality of its rulers cannot claim to be civilized.
Emperor Norton was no freak. Emperor Norton was one of the greatest statesmen in human history. It is difficult to find a statesman of similar stature in the brutal history of politics, perhaps with the exception of Ashoka the Great (304–232 BCE), ruler of the Mauryan Empire, who entered the history books for his radical transformation: after having been a brutal tyrant, he renounced violence and dedicated himself wholeheartedly to the well-being of the humans and animals within his realm. Humanity needs more leaders like Emperor Norton.
Incidentally, Archduke Arthur of Duckionary is a distant relative of Emperor Norton. Admittedly, the kinship is very distant indeed, but it is real. Furthermore, it is not known that any other living relatives of Emperor Norton are active as micronational monarchs. In this sense, a spark of the heritage and legacy of Emperor Norton’s reign also lives on within the Parliamentary Monarchy of Duckionary.





